Images From the Stonewall Uprising’s Final Night

The Stonewall uprising that began 40 years ago this month in Greenwich Village has come to be seen as a defining event in the development of the gay rights movement, but little visual evidence has survived from the six nights of the disturbances, in which gay men fought back against a pattern of police harassment.

A series of photographs that were taken by a New York Times photographer on the sixth and final night of the disturbances, but not published, has surfaced, offering what David Carter, who wrote a comprehensive history of the riots in 2004, says are the only known images from the uprising’s tumultuous finale.

The images were shot by a Times photographer named Larry Morris on the evening of Wednesday, July 2, 1969, five nights after a raid on the Stonewall Inn, a nightclub on Christopher Street popular among gay men and lesbians, touched off the disturbances.

As Mr. Carter explains in his book “Stonewall: The Riots That Sparked the Gay Revolution,” protesters, most of them young gay men in the Village, were angered by articles about the disturbances published that day in The Village Voice that were seen as disparaging of gays. In addition, Mr. Carter wrote, some nongay activists from radical leftist organizations had descended on the Village, impressed by the riots as an example of resistance to authority.

By around 10 p.m. on July 2, a crowd that The Times estimated at 500 had gathered outside the Stonewall Inn. Some began shoving and throwing bottles; others set fire to garbage at Christopher Street and Waverly Place. Riot officers from the Police Department’s Tactical Patrol Force, wearing helmets and armed with nightsticks, descended on the scene. By the evening’s end, numerous people had been injured, including a patrolman who was struck on the face and had to be treated at a hospital, and at least five people were arrested.

The Times published a short article the next day, “Hostile Crowd Dispersed Near Sheridan Square,” but did not include Mr. Morris’s photographs.

The photographs remained away from public review for nearly four decades. In 2006, a photography researcher for The Times found the original prints and, noticing that the captions on the photographs identified them as being of the Stonewall riots, scanned the images into the newspaper’s internal image database. Eventually the pictures were logged in by Redux Pictures, a photo agency that sells stock photographs and has an arrangement with The Times.

And in April, The Times published one of the images to accompany an article in the Week in Review section, with the caption: “The Village, 1969: Near the Stonewall Bar in Greenwich Village a week after the raid and rebellion.”

At the same time, Dana Kirchoff, an archival researcher working on a documentary film about Stonewall for the PBS history series “American Experience,” encountered the images on the Redux Web site. Since March, she had been poring over records at the New York Public Library, identifying news photographers who were active in the Stonewall era in the hopes of encountering previously unpublished images from the riots.

In a telephone interview, Mr. Carter called The Times’s images “extremely important” from a historical perspective, because only a handful of images from the riots survive. They include a photograph taken by a freelancer, Joseph Ambrosini, from the first night of the riots and published in The Daily News, and some posed images taken by Fred McDarrah for The Village Voice from the second night of the riots.

“I’m very grateful The Times preserved and cataloged them,” Mr. Carter said of the images from the final night of the riots. “This is a wonderful gift for the gay community to get in the month of the 40th anniversary of the riots.”

Comments are no longer being accepted.

Perley J. Thibodeau June 1, 2009 · 4:23 pm

HAPPY GAY PRIDE MONTH
“You’ve come a long way, Babies.”

reneebillie@optonline.net June 1, 2009 · 4:24 pm

I had a terrible incident occur during l969 by Tompkin Square Park which cast a shadow over my life for decades.I was tramatized, hassassed with words I cant eescribe. I dont even want to print it. Its got me in tears to this day. Thank you for shedding a bit of light on circumstances of the day and times.

Certainly a threatening looking crowd, eh? Those polished loafers, creased chinos and pressed short sleeve dress shirts make them hard to discern from the undercover guys…except they weren’t cruising. I recall the scenes of the neighborhood like it was yesterday. Thanks.

Thank you for sharing these photos. Their rarity has probably more to do with homophobia than the mere passage of time that inevitably leads to much lost history. Imagine the coverage a 6-day riot would garner now…

Hell’s Kitchen Guy June 1, 2009 · 5:28 pm

Nice that they weren’t thrown out, but considering the Times’ attitude about gays and gay rights until about 15 years ago, I’m not surprised they were ignored.

The more things change, the more they stay the same. I knew a woman who was invited to apply as a police officer in Dallas during the 80’s. She described how the application asked if you were homosexual, and because she answered honestly that she is lesbian, she was denied the job. I found it hard to believe then. I find it hard to believe now.

It does indeed seem peculiar that in a century when just about everything was photographed, Stonewall was not. I guess police raids on gay bars were just not news.

lets riot!

“Those polished loafers, creased chinos and pressed short sleeve dress shirts…”

Yes, and despite the mythology that has developed over the past 40 years, it was guys like them who constituted the majority of the Stonewall’s clientele and the crowds in the streets, NOT the drag queens, who showed up once word got out that the gays were, at long last, fighting back. Viva Stonewall!

Hell’s Kitchen Guy June 1, 2009 · 6:26 pm

tt – 7 – that’s not quite fair. At the time, it was considered a “disturbance,” hardly a riot and certainly not the historical marker it has become. Often, important events only become so in retrospect. And there were photographers there — see Carter’s book and other tomes. There’s the famous photograph in front of Stonewall with a defiant-looking young man staring right into the camera, as if to say, “I’m here, I’m queer, and I’m not hiding it.”

We’re still fighting the same fight.

As I like to say, No more Ms. Nice Queer.

Is it true that the riot was in some way connected to the death of Judy Garland?

A real find and special thanks to David Carter for validating them. Not surprising that they were buried in the archives. Queers didn’t matter in those days.

Read “Stonewall” by David Carter. Judy Garland’s death had very little or nothing to do with the riots.

Perley J. Thibodeau June 2, 2009 · 1:13 pm

WAYNE SUNDAY
Are you saying that Judy died in vain?

I’m not surprised the images went unpublished, considered not newsworthy, and remained for all intents “lost” for nearly 40 years. The institutionalized homophobia of The New York Times contributed in no small part to the oppression of gays and lesbians in NYC and beyond for many, many years. I did a casual analysis of their gay coverage a while back — from sodomite to homosexual to sexual invert to pervert to deviant to, finally, gay:

//thornyc.livejournal.com/241086.html

I was there at the Stonewall. I was detained but not arrested in the bar. I was let go by the police and went out onto the street and the riot had started. I had been to a wedding of a straight friend in the Village that night and stopped by the bar and it happened. I had been in anti Vietnam War rallies and other civil rights movements. At that time, I did not quite equate this riot with the civil rights movement but it made sense. But……that night, those nights, blacks, hispanics and other oppressed minorities joined us and the fight began.

Not won but the fight began. So each of you, keep this fight for equality for all peoples going.

It’s up to YOU not somebody else.

Michael

Christian Montone June 2, 2009 · 10:07 pm

It is both inspiring and very humbling to see these images. I have had the benefit of living in a post-Stonewall world which I KNOW would not be the same had these events not occured. These photos inspire me because I know those streets very well… they show me not only what they looked like before my life began, but also remind me what had to be endured. They also show far we have ALL come as people (gay, straight and everything inbetween) but also remind me of how far we need to go in terms of all cities and towns across this nation. To see these pictures as the marriage debate continues to go back and forth puts a bit of a lump in my throat.

The echoes of Stone Wall still reverberate throughout America. I would not exactly call it a riot, I might call it a call to the nation that we are here to stay and we will not put up with the racist like attitude that is still prevalent in much of society still today.

A large oil company (and others) still do not have anti discrimination (against gay people) to this day. I know other large corporations have a do not ask do not tell policy. The US military services (and others) have the same attitude. We have made baby steps but we have a LONG way to go.

One prime example is gay marriages. Of all the states I would have thought that California would not vote down gay marriage. I am guessing it was (in no small part) due to outside influences (like the Mormon Church). The US is still mired in religious fanaticism. If the religious types would keep to themselves no one would mind. The issues is when the Church(s) decide to cross the line between religious ideology and politics.

Until the US comes to deal with these types of people and respects their beliefs and integrates other people under one nation we will have this type discrimination.

I am NOT suggesting that the discrimination of gays is anything like the black discrimination. I am suggesting that people need to understand and respect other people. This is the fundamental right of all humans is to be safe and to be able to make a living doing work that helps each other.

Perley J. Thibodeau June 3, 2009 · 1:21 pm

“The Night That Larry Krammer Kissed Me,” was an off Broadway show about a young man who came to New York.
In it, when his mother finds out that he’s gay she orders him out of the house shouting vehemently;
“There’s a place for people like you.”
He blithely replies;
“Yes. New York.
For those who don’t know, Larry Krammer is a highly respected world famous playright and author.
I was wearing a frilly lace and flowered hat at a party in Manhattan’s Cty Hall a few years back and Larry Krammer came up to me, took my hand, kissed it and told me that I was beautiful.
I thanked him.
I’ll always remember, “The Night That Larry Krammer Kissed Me.”

Perley J. Thibodeau June 3, 2009 · 2:43 pm

This won’t get posted but, here goes.
The New York Times has changed a lot in its conservative attitude since it used to sell for 5 cents on the open news stand.
I was told by a male employee that when Jackie Kennedy-Onassis died the writers in the News Room were talking and, one male employee said in sincere sadness;
“Poor John-John. I wonder if there is anything that I can do to console him?”
Another writer replied;
“Yes, leave him alone.”
The eyes and ears of Perley J. Thibodeau are everywhere.
Even in the New York Times’ Newsroom.

I wasn’t at Stonewall but here in Ontario Canada….harrassment by police at the gay bars was not uncommon..raids occurred and the neighbors threw stones and jerred. Things really haven’t changed…..kids are still made to feel less of a human because of their sexual orientation. We are tolerated …is this an improvement after 40 years?

To all the brave gays who risk harm to stand up for their rights – from Stonewall to present: You have my sincere respect and admiration.

To all the cops who respond with brutality: Your corrupt ‘blue wall’ culture is a blight on our great city.

Assaulting people for the way they love is madness. Gay-bashing cops/thugs- and other homophobic nastiness – sickens me.

I’m raising my sons to bash gay-bashers and despise cops.

This year, the theme for the San Francisco Pride Parade is”Stonewall 40 SF Pride”.

My partner and i were married at SF City Hall last June, and are still married according to the California Supreme Court.
We are marching in the parade to support marriage equality for all.

The Stonewall Riot (or disturbance, if you prefer) is still inspiring to so many of us.

How oddly calm everything looks in these photos. The tourists in Times Square today look more like a “riot.”

To try to make Stonewall about Judy Garland cheapens and trivialises a seminal historical event.

Perley – Kramer is one M.