The Stanley Cup — not the one full of coffee knocked over by Dwight Schrute — is about to divide one of television’s most beloved couples.

The St. Louis Blues clinched their spot in the Stanley Cup Final on Tuesday night with a Game 6 win over the San Jose Sharks, which means they’ll face the Boston Bruins in a rematch of the 1970 series that the Bruins swept.

Here’s where The Office comes in: John Krasinski is a Bruins fan. The Pam to his Jim, Jenna Fischer, roots for the Blues. And the pair of actors noted as much on Twitter after St. Louis clinched:

As Stanley — the character, not the Cup — would say, I DO NOT THINK THIS IS FUNNY. Do not let this come between you two!! It’s just sports!

I know, I know, they’re actors. Jim and Pam aren’t real. But maybe you two can spice up your real-world friendship and make a bet ahead of the Final?

[jwplayer xmgyMOHY-q2aasYxh]